Choice Insurance Agency

Contact Us

Providing tailored insurance solutions in Massachusetts and beyond.

Request a Quote


Contact Info

Hours of Operation
Monday to Friday | 8:30am – 4:30pm

choice@choice-insurance.com
Call Us | 800-649-4853

Choice Insurance Agency, Inc

Fitchburg Office

376 Summer Street Finchburg, MA 01420

Legere Insurance Agency, Inc

Leominster Office

165 Mechanic Street Leominster, MA 01453

Client Services

Client Services

Policy Changes

Client Services

Request Certificate

Client Services

Billing & Payments

Client Services

File a
Claim

Client Services

Get a Quote

Explore our Insurance Coverage Offerings

As Independent Agents for Choice Insurance in Massachusetts, we’re here to handpick the perfect carrier that suits your insurance needs. We’re not tied down to any single insurance company – our loyalty lies with you. When life hits you with a loss, count on us to ensure you get fair, speedy payments and top-notch service. We’ve curated a lineup of financially strong and respected insurance companies, making it possible for us to deliver the best coverage at the most competitive rates.

Words from our Clients

Gained a customer for life.

Moved all my personal lines of insurance over to Choice. They found me a set of policies that saved me over $1000/year. Then, Julie took care of my commercial line, jumped through so many hoops and got me a policy for my business at an amazing rate.

Great people, great insurance, great advice, great price.

Kristoffer S., Google Review

Choice insurance has been providing insurance coverage to our commercial real estate business for over 7 years and the service has been tremendous. Peter has always responded quickly and with incredibly aggressive pricing; and with a perspective to assure that we are fully covered for all potential issues without unnecessary coverage and fees. There is such a comfort when working with Peter and his company that our best interest is their top priority.

Mike R., Google Review

I have been a happy customer of Choice Insurance for 12+ years. Peter and the team have been fantastic — always professional and knowledgeable about supporting my business insurance needs as well as our personal, home, car, and condo insurance needs. Peter has helped us with insurance questions related to buying and selling homes, a flood insurance claim, a tree that almost fell on our house and destroyed our fence, and a car accident. Recently, Peter noticed that our condo insurance (inherited from the prior owner) was severely inadequate. He helped us switch to a much better policy within less than a day. And, thank goodness he did. A couple weeks later, I smelled gas outside our home. It was a gas leak that National Grid fixed right away. But, I slept more soundly that night knowing that if the worst had happened, we would be fully covered thanks to Peter! I can’t recommend Choice enough!

Christine A., Google Review
This is our third policy with Peter, he’s awesome!! We started with a policy for a commercial space and added a home insurance and auto policy because of the quality of service that we received.
We highly recommend Choice Insurance Agency for competitive pricing and transparency. Want a great policy and customer service experience look no further.
M. Maxwell, Google Review

Peter and his team are thorough and have a strong sense of urgency for all matters pertaining to our account. Each time we reach out for assistance, our expectations are exceeded. I would recommend his team to anyone.

Chris C., Google Review

I switched to Choice 10 years ago and with 2 teenage drivers we interact frequently. Every time they have made the process quick and effortless. My family and I could not be more pleased.

Matthew P., Google Review
Choice Insurance Agency

We love to hear from our clients! Your feedback helps us continue to improve our service and insurance offerings.